found drama

get oblique

Dozois’ 24th Annual Collection

by Rob Friesel

As with many “Year’s Best” type anthologies (regardless of genre), it is difficult to evaluate Gardner Dozois’ The Year’s Best Science Fiction: Twenty-Fourth Annual Collection as if it were a whole. Unlike a themed collection (e.g., Wastelands: Stories of the Apocalypse), you cannot easily ask how each story is helping to advance or otherwise round-out the speculation or evaluation of that given theme. But that’s OK; that’s not why we pick up and read a collection like this. And it’s a hazard we’re willing — nay: happy — to take on.

That said, the rating for the collection here is a computed average of my ratings on the individual stories themselves. Out to four decimal places, the 24th Annual Collection scores: 3.3929

And now for the individual ratings 1 based on the 5-star scale used at

  1. “I, Row-Boat” (Cory Doctorow) – ★★★
  2. “Julian: A Christmas Story” (Robert Charles Wilson ) – ★★★
    • Not sure how this one sits with me; a re-read might better inform whether it’s holding up Christianity or vs. some ethical secularism but… Tough to say on the first hit. Also: steampunkish and yet not; definitely a post-Peak Oil tale and I wonder to myself if it wasn’t short-listed for inclusion in Wastelands or not.
  3. “Tin Marsh” (Michael Swanwick) – ★★
  4. “The Djinn’s Wife” (Ian McDonald) – ★★★?
    • If you’re too intimidated by River of Gods then this will almost serve as a substitute.
  5. “The House Beyond Your Sky” (Benjamin Rosenbaum) – ★★★
    • Attempts depth but comes off as a bit opaque. A compact, dense story though and probably worth a re-read sometime.
  6. “Where The Golden Apples Grow” (Kage Baker) – ★★★
    • Interesting and twisted take on the “Prince and the Pauper” fairy tale (though with two paupers). I wanted to like it a lot more but I found the story a bit predictable and maybe just a little pedantic. But I’m curious to see more by this gifted writer.
  7. “Kin” (Bruce McAllister) – ★★
    • Couldn’t relate; felt forced. Also: where’s “the greater good” in exceptions?
  8. “Signal to Noise” (Alastair Reynolds) – ★★★★★
    • Wow; head-spinningly good.
  9. “The Big Ice” (Jay Lake & Ruth Nestvold) – ★★★
    • Action for action; great for what it is.
  10. “Bow Shock” (Gregory Benford) – ★★★
  11. “In the River” (Justin Stanchfield) – ★★★★★
    • This is a good one to rub up against Blindsight for comparison.
  12. “Incarnation Day” (Walter Jon Williams) – ★★★?
    • Nice use of voice and tone; also: it’s like a post-human Pinocchio!
  13. “Far As You Can Go” (Greg Van Eekhout) – ★★★?
  14. “Good Mountain” (Robert Reed) – ★★★
    • Had trouble getting into this one; too far afield?
  15. “I Hold My Father’s Paws” (David D. Levine) – ★★★
  16. “Dead Men Walking” (Paul J. McAuley) – ★★
  17. “Home Movies” (Mary Rosenblum) – ★★★
    • A la PKD, but not enough D.
  18. “Damascus” (Daryl Gregory) – ★★★
    • I liked this better as that X-Files episode 2  Also: I don’t get the title. (Seems such a shame, had so much potential…)
  19. “Life on the Preservation” (Jack Skillingstead) – ★★
    • I wanted to like it but it seemed like a bit of a warm-up…
  20. “Yellow Card Man” (Paolo Bacigalupi) – ★★★?
    • Heavy and cynical and intense and sometimes a little hard to follow. Worth a re-read to pull it all together.
  21. “Riding the Crocodile” (Greg Egan) – ★★★
  22. “The Ile of Dogges” (Elizabeth Bear & Sarah Monette) – ★★
    • Trying to hard to be exactly what it is?
  23. “The Highway Men” (Ken MacLeod) – ★★★?
  24. “The Pacific Mystery” (Stephen Baxter) – ★★★?
  25. “Okanoggan Falls” (Carolyn Ives Gilman) – ★★★?
  26. “Every Hole Is Outlined” (John Barnes) – ★★★?
  27. “The Town on Blighted Sea” (A.M. Dellamonica) – ★★★★★
  28. “Nightingale” (Alastair Reynolds) – ★★★★★

BONUS ROUND: a quick detail of the reading pace (for comparison purposes only):

Reading Pace for...

Click through for full size.

Review originally published on

  1. With comments where I have them…[]
  2. You know the one I’m talking about?  The one from Season Two?[]

About Rob Friesel

Software engineer by day. Science fiction writer by night. Weekend homebrewer, beer educator at Black Flannel, and Certified Cicerone. Author of The PhantomJS Cookbook and a short story in Please Do Not Remove. View all posts by Rob Friesel →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *