found drama

get oblique

Homebrew #96: Honestatis (Mk. IX)

by Rob Friesel

It had been too long. Mk. VIII was… summer of 2018!? Did all of 2019 slip by without a single batch of Honestatis? I suppose it’s possible — we were busy last year. But as 2019 closed out and I looked ahead to 2020, I committed to two seemingly opposed brew goals. The first? Brew at least six new-to-me styles. And the second? Start the year off strong with the triumphant return of Honestatis, the beer I’ve brewed more than any other:

I’ve quipped more than once that Honestatis was the beer I was born to drink. Enough smoke to know it’s a smoked beer, but not to overwhelm you. Rye enough to get a strong impression of its earthy/spicy qualities. Definite red color. The residual sweetness that the red color demands, but not cloying. Decidedly bitter, but not aggressively so, nor hoppy. A beer with enough complexity to be interesting, but not so much that you couldn’t just enjoy its simplicity.

And maybe only a beer that it’s creator could love?

Except that my friend Dan seems to have fallen in love with it, too?

Enough so that we collaborate on Mk. VII and managed a 42 in first round NHC 2018.


So yeah, it was time to re-brew this bad boy…

Brew Day

Before we dive into the brew day details, there are a few details to get out of the way up front.

First, this was the triumphant return of 1332. I’d gotten spooked off of it after Prosody (Mosaic) 1 — but it was time to conquer my fears, apply the knowledge I’d learned, and go back to my roots on this one.

Which is just as well because…

Secondly: I had to do a 1:1 swap of cherrywood smoked malt (which I’ve always used for this beer) with beechwood smoked malt — which was all that I could get my hands on without either inconveniencing myself or else compromising my values. So… rolling the dice on that.

Which was a gamble because…

I’d already committed to this being beer #1 of 2020, but in the January meeting of the North Seattle Homebrewers … I kind of threw down the gauntlet for a smoked beers duel. Kind of. Maybe. Definitely.

Cherrywood smoked malt or not (NOT) — the brew day must go on.

First things first: yeast — I’ve been spoiled by those Imperial Yeast packs so I finally dusted off my stir plate for my beloved 1332:

Honestatis (Mk. IX) brew day

Morning of brew day came and…

  1. Mashed in at 154ºF for a bit over 90 minutes (pH 5.42)
  2. Pre-boil gravity 1.058
  3. 1.25 oz. Warrior FWH
  4. Vigorous boil for 60 minutes
  5. Some Willamette at flame-out
  6. 5.25 gal. of 1.076 wort into the fermentor
  7. Pitch at 66ºF
Honestatis (Mk. IX) brew day

ASIDE: Mini-Retro on the Brew Day

While it went well overall… WTF is up with my brew house efficiency here? Regular readers will remember how I was trying to puzzle this out, only to learn of other potential complicating factors. Regardless, I stuck to my original conclusions and planned for a 65% brew house efficiency because my planned O.G. had ticked up over the 1.065 mark. But hey — that was ignoring the slope, and trying to attribute a kind of strict binary division. Meanwhile my actual BHE comes out as 77.1% which… significantly above all the estimates.

In other words: I’ve got more work to do there.


I pitched my starter when the wort was around 66ºF. I decanted down to approx. 200 ml of slurry from 1000 ml of starter. I locked in my controller at 67±1ºF.

The beer was fermenting vigorously within hours.

Within a week things had settled down (blow-off bucket activity-wise) and so I swapped what I could, as safely as I could. (There was a lot of yeasty stuff in that blow-off bucket, by the way.)

Refractometer at this point was telling me 9.8ºBx which BeerSmith was converting to 1.016. Doubtful it was that low, but probably in the ballpark. Regardless — that tiny refractometer sample was tasting young and it needed more time to mature.

Two weeks after brew day, I draw off a hydrometer sample and prepare to package it.

Honestatis (Mk. IX)

Wherein F.G. reads 1.017 and final ABV is something like 7.9%. Or as my notes put it: “that’s just what this beer wants to be.” And so into the keg it goes to carbonate and finish clearing.

Overall Impressions

I can tell the difference in the smoked malt with respect to the flavor contribution, but I still like it. (And it won!)

Honestatis (Mk. IX)

AROMA. Leads with moderately strong woodsmoke notes — mostly evocative of campfire. Moderate toasty-rich malt; low bread crust. Low woodsy and earthy and floral hop notes. Very low berry-like ester, otherwise fermentation seems clean.

APPEARANCE. Copper colored with vivid red-gold highlight. Khaki head of dense, persistent foam. Notable lacing and legs. Moderate haze. 2 Many fine, fast-rising bubbles.

FLAVOR. As with aroma, leads with moderately strong woodsmoke impression. Balance tilts to malt — moderately strong toasted bread impression with low caramel accents and background earthy-spicy notes. Hop impression woodsy & floral — mostly retronasal. Medium firm bitterness. Medium-dry finish. Aftertaste of campfire and a moderately low residual sweetness. No significant esters. No noted off-flavors. Very low perfumy alcohol note in the finish.

MOUTHFEEL. Medium-full body. Medium carbonation. Light astringency. Mild creaminess. Gentle alcohol warming.

OVERALL IMPRESSION. For competition purposes… Very Good, maybe Excellent beer — but given what I want this beer to be… I can tell that it’s missing the Briess cherrywood smoked malt. That being said, it does a good job of bringing the smoke flavor front-and-center (as always) without hitting you over the head with it. My knocks/dings on this beer are all minor things – clarity and the detectable astringency, mostly. (To speak freely: this is a beer that Dan and I have gotten pretty well dialed-in and it’s… good. It’s just also that this is a pretty niche beer.)

Were I scoring it in competition? High 30s? 37? (Again: it’s a niche beer, but between my original vision and Dan’s tweaks… we have it more or less where we want it.)

Changes for next time? Get the Briess cherrywood smoked malt back. Otherwise I’m pretty happy with it. Maybe see if I can suss out some of the minor astringency and/or clarity concerns. I’m also glad I brought back the 1332 for this one. That said… I still think that a lager version might be interesting, especially after the 1007 experiment on Mk. VIII.


The all-grain (BIAB) recipe for Honestatis (Mk. IX) is as follows:

Water Chemistry

Starting with the Seattle municipal water profile (carbon filtered) as a base:

Target values in ppm
Ca Mg Na SO4²- Cl- HCO3-
50.0 10.1 15.0 75.0 63.0 40.0


  • 4 lb. 12 oz. Briess 2-row brewers malt
  • 4 lb. 12 oz. Great Western rye malt
  • 3 lb. BEST Red X malt
  • 1 lb. 8 oz. BEST Smoked malt
  • 12 oz. melanoidin malt
  • 5 oz. 40L caramel malt

Hop Schedule

  • 1.25 oz. Warrior (FWH)
  • 2 oz. Willamette (flame-out)


Wyeast 1332 Northwest Ale (2 packs); 1000 ml starter

Brew Day

  1. Collect 31.74 qt. water and heat to 161.4ºF. Mash in; hold at 152ºF for 90 minutes. No mash out.
  2. Remove filter bag from water. Squeeze filter bag to extract as much liquid as possible for wort. No sparge. Pre-boil volume should be 6.75 gallons.
  3. Bring to a boil. Boil for 60 minutes; follow hop schedule as described above.
  4. Cool to <70ºF as rapidly as possible. Post-boil volume should be approx. 5.25 gallons.
  5. Aerate wort; pitch 1332 yeast from starter.
  6. Start fermentation at 66±2ºF.

Beyond Brew Day

  1. Allow fermentation to complete (approx. 2 weeks) at approx. 66-68ºF.
  2. After reaching terminal gravity, keg the beer and carbonate to 2.5 vols. Allow to condition and clear.
  3. Serve and enjoy.


Honestatis (Mk. IX), a smoked extra amber ale by Tilde Gravitywerks

Original Gravity 1.076
Final Gravity 1.017
ABV 7.9%
Attenuation 76.5%
IBU 52
SRM 13
Links Untappd
  1. “I’m sorry I made you drink that.”[]
  2. Got clearer from initial notes! but then I took the keg 1.5 miles down the road for competition and that was enough to agitate it.[]

About Rob Friesel

Software engineer by day. Science fiction writer by night. Weekend homebrewer, beer educator at Black Flannel, and Certified Cicerone. Author of The PhantomJS Cookbook and a short story in Please Do Not Remove. View all posts by Rob Friesel →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *